This episode picks up with Yuuki and Mirai riding towards their home in the army truck when Yuuki asks Mirai what she would do if he was dead? Mirai tells Yuuki not to say strange things and that mother, father, and she would probably cry themselves to death.
Soon, Mirai and Yuuki exit the army truck and head towards home where Mirai runs into Mayu who lets her know that Mirai’s mother, and father survived the earthquake. Mirai’s mother is taking shelter at the elementary school, and her father was injured but doing OK at the local hospital.
After Mirai finds that her mother went home to get some clothing, she goes looking for Yuuki who has headed inside the elementary school classroom areas. Mirai runs into Yuuki’s friend, Itsuki, and together they search the school grounds for Yuuki. As Mirai searches the school, she comes across some of Yuuki’s classroom artwork and begins to cry, Mirai is unable to explain to Itsuki why she’s crying. At various times, Yuuki appears to Mirai telling her not to cry, but vanishes as soon as Itsuki appears.
As time passes, Itsuki becomes worried about Mirai’s strange behavior and he tells her to come to his house so he can give Mirai a journal that he and Yuuki have been keeping. When they arrive at Itsuki’s home, Mirai notices a danger notice posted on the door, but Itsuki goes inside anyways. As Mirai tries to call him back outside, she also sees Yuuki enter the house, so Mirai has to follow them in. When Itsuki hands Mirai the book, an aftershock strikes the area and she grabs Itsuki to protect him from the falling debris. Mirai then notices Yuuki in the hallway, so she drags Itsuki over to Yuuki and cover them both up. A few seconds later, the part of the house where Itsuki and Mirai were in has collapsed but Mirai and Itsuki are safe, but Yuuki has disappeared again.
Yuuki then appears before Mirai where he calls her name; Then the truth comes flooding into Mirai’s mind. Yuuki died outside the hospital, the medical workers tried to bring him back but failed, the scene where Mirai was looking at his death certificate in the hallway was real, and it seems that Mirai was blocking out everything from when the sunlight reflected in her eyes as she was walking up to the hospital. Yuuki then tells Mirai that he’s dead, and as tears begin to roll down Mirai’s cheeks, the episode ends.
Well, most of us knew what was coming, and the only questions were how long would it take and was Yuuki a delusion inside Mirai’s mind or was he some sort of ghost? After watching this episode I think that Yuuki was a combination of both Mirai’s mind and a helpful spirit; Mirai’s mind up until now was unable to fully adjust to the truth of her brother’s death and was suppressing everything after the flash of light in her eyes, but her mind was trying to remember the truth and Yuuki’s ghost/spirit was just there to be with Mirai until she was ready to handle the truth, it might be painful, but Mirai can now handle the truth.
Now, I think Mirai will have to go and find Mari and retrieve Yuuki’s backpack and bring Yuuki fully home to their family. I feel the backpack contains Yuuki’s death certificate and maybe even his ashes, and once Mirai brings Yuuki home her family can then perform the proper Buddhist/Shinto death rites for her brother, Yuuki’s spirit can then rest in peace until they invite him home for Obon and he can live on in their memories.
My problem with the “Yuuki ghost” storyline is that I felt that they dragged it out for way too long. TM 8.0 was supposed to be a realistic look at the aftermath of monstrously deadly earthquake and while mental problems with survivors is an issue, the “Yuuki” thing went over the top. I could see Mirai having a temporary mental break as plausible, and I could even understand “Yuuki” as a ghost. But, I feel by combining Mirai’s mental problems with Yuuki as a ghost was really too much. I think that this is too bad because I felt that TM 8.0 was heading towards becoming a truly great anime, and now I’m going to place it in the “well above average class”. I’m really looking forward to a realistic wrap up to the series without any stupid twists like, maybe Mirai or her parents dying, or even Mari dying. Life needs to go on for the living, and let the dead be a warm memory of the past.
September 13, 2009 at 8:30 am
I feel that it’s too early to conclude that this development seriously derails the progression to quality this series has taken. The claims to realism I took as those made to reflect the depiction of physical earthquake dynamics and nothing more.
September 13, 2009 at 9:18 am
I wouldn’t say that the “Yuuki” issue truly spoils that whole story but I would say that that this series had a change to transcend many of the common “tropes” found in anime series.
It seems that at times, anime writers and directors just can’t pass up an opportunity to take things a bit too far, but it might be understandable because they might feel that age demographic they’re shooting at needs to be hit over the head a little more than necessary.
September 13, 2009 at 2:34 pm
WTF, a ghost? Where did you see a ghost? Tokyo Magnitude 8.0 is a realistic series which used an unreliable narrator to spice things up a little.
Maybe “most of you” (blog writers?) knew what was going on (which surprises me, because you don’t know what is going on *now*), but as someone who watches anime casually and doesn’t waste time analyzing or guessing anything, it was a nice twist for me this week. I knew something was wrong with Mari since the end of episode 8, but didn’t bother with it (I thought she had bad news about the kids’ parents). As a result, I enjoyed this more than you.
This was a lot more interesting than simply having him drop dead in the middle of the street and filling the rest of the episodes with depressed faces. It also only took one episode (9), and it’s not like that one was uneventful or centered about that particular issue.
Did someone else see the brother? Did he say anything that would have been impossible for her to know? No? Then it’s not a ghost, simple as that.
September 13, 2009 at 6:38 pm
No, I would not have preferred having Yuuki just drop dead in the middle of the street and having the rest of the episodes filled with depression.
The reason why I, and many other “blog Writers” make the Yuuki is a ghost/spirit suggestion is that Mirai’s “Yuuki” doesn’t operate quite like a delusion should function. Most delusional people I’ve met don’t have their delusions disappear as soon as someone comes near them, the delusion stays with them and you can clearly tell that somethings wrong with them.
Also, In Japanese Shinto cultural belief system the concept of a person’s ghost/spirit is different than in the Christian belief system. Under Shinto, a spirit that has not been put to proper rest through the proper rituals may still stay around for awhile if it feels that it has unfinished obligations (Guri) in this world.
So, it’s quite possible that “ghost” Yuuki might feel that he still has the duty to help find Mari’s loved ones, help save Itsuki, and help his mentally weakened sister come to terms with her loss and make it back to their family.
I’m sorry if us blog writers speculate on, or analyze a anime series, but if we didn’t do this type of writing all we would be able to do is say I really like or dislike this or that series, very boring indeed.
September 20, 2009 at 10:32 am
Wow.. very good the way you knowledgably reminded us of the Japanese context of the show, I guess we must never forget that when watching anime! 🙂
September 17, 2009 at 1:31 pm
[…] “felt that they dragged it out for way too long” (referring to the Yuuki ghost arc for the last 3 […]
November 23, 2009 at 12:59 am
TM8 = most depressing anime
I have a love/hate relationship with this series. The twist definitely evoked powerful emotions from me. However, I do agree that they took it too far because it was too sad :p. I too was expecting and hoping (and perhaps preferring as well) a more realistic (and happier) ending. I think I definitely would have liked it better with a realistic ending, but I can’t deny that this ending is what really made this series powerful and shocking.
November 23, 2009 at 3:48 am
I don’t know if a happier ending would have been more realistic but the power of the ending comes from the fact that we fans come to care for the main characters and it hurts us we they get injured or die. Yuuki was the embodiment of his name (strength/courage) for Mirai (the future.
November 23, 2009 at 6:17 pm
True, however by a realistic ending, I meant removing the ghost hallucinations completely towards the end of the show. I think by removing it altogether, the ending would not necessarily be a happy one, but one that is less sad because the ghost hallucinations really struck a chord in me. Up to that point (about half into the series), it had been a pretty realistic show.
November 23, 2009 at 6:58 pm
If you remove the ghost hallucinations from TM 8.0 you would be removing the Japanese cultural influences from the series, and while that might make the series more acceptable to a western viewer it would be betraying its Japanese viewers.
I don’t view the ghost plot-line as being sad but a celebration of Japanese beliefs. Please do me a favor and read these two blogs posts of mine and then re-watch the last half of the series straight through with no breaks then drop me a comment.
https://animewriter.wordpress.com/category/japanese-misc/japanese-death-beliefs-customs/
November 23, 2009 at 8:46 pm
Actually I’m Asian and already familiar with the Japanese customs and beliefs about death. I do agree with you that removing the ghost hallucinations would be a “betrayal” to Japanese customs, in addition to the fact that the show would not be as riveting without it.
November 24, 2009 at 7:46 pm
Agreed.
October 30, 2011 at 4:40 am
Portable Building Systems…
[…]Tokyo Magnitude 8.0 episode 10; Taking a good thing too far. « Crystal Tokyo Anime Blog[…]…
September 20, 2020 at 10:49 pm
Self Improvement Coach
Tokyo Magnitude 8.0 episode 10; Taking a good thing too far. | Crystal Tokyo Anime Blog
October 16, 2020 at 2:04 pm
more about vote.bookmarkstar.com
Tokyo Magnitude 8.0 episode 10; Taking a good thing too far. | Crystal Tokyo Anime Blog
October 28, 2020 at 11:00 am
relationship issues
Tokyo Magnitude 8.0 episode 10; Taking a good thing too far. | Crystal Tokyo Anime Blog